skip to main content skip to footer

Specializing In Off-Premises Catering


639 Commack Rd
Commack, NY 11725
Phone: (631) 486-5126
Fax: (631) 486-5129

Bagel Basket Cafe Reviews


I picked up two bagels with cream cheese here and was very impressed. I got an onion bagel and a flat everything bagel (I think they called it a flagel?). I got lox cream cheese and veggie cream cheese on the side. Both of the bagels were absolutely delicious even though I ate the bagels the next day. The vegetable cream cheese was good but the lox cream cheese was amazing! The best food of my New York trip was definitely the cream cheese!

Vivi T.

Breakfast Sandwich with pickle

Breakfast Sandwiches

Two paninis on tray


Lettuce in plastic container

Grab & Go Salads

Bagel Basket Cafe

639 Commack Rd
Commack, NY 11725
Tel: 631-486-5126
Fax: 631-486-5129
Get Directions